May 13, · When you are assigned to write a problem-solution essay or research paper, choosing a good topic is the first dilemma you need to work out. The world is full of issues that need to be resolved or could be improved upon, and unlike the Konigsberg Bridge problem from the s, most of them have a potential solution Our police and prisons cannot heal the breeding conditions of crime. Our pesticides cannot restore ruined soil. Covid recalls the good old days when the challenges of infectious diseases succumbed to modern medicine and hygiene, at the same time as the Nazis succumbed to the war machine, and nature itself succumbed, or so it seemed, to Essay Fountain: A custom essay writing service that sells original assignment help services to students. We provide essay writing services, other custom assignment help services, and research materials for references purposes only. Students should ensure that they reference the materials obtained from our website appropriately
IELTS Essay - Certain prisoners should be made to do unpaid community work
After the recession inHarriet Krzykowski was hired as a mental health aide at the Dade Correctional Institution, a prison in South Florida. But the low pay bothered her far less than hearing about guards visiting abuse on the mentally ill prisoners entrusted to her care. Some of these prisoners were being starved, Ms. Krzykowski was told. Others were locked inside a scalding shower.
Among the prisoners subjected to this sadistic punishment was Darren Rainey, a mentally ill man who collapsed in the stall and died. Autopsy photos later leaked to the press showed that much do prisons work essay the skin on Mr. When she learned of Mr. Krzykowski wanted to quit her job. She needed the paycheck she drew to support her family. So she kept silent.
Krzykowski could be viewed as an enabler and accomplice. But there is also another way to see her: as a worker performing a function that society tacitly condones but prefers not to hear too much about. To the extent they are noticed at all, the people who perform such functions tend to be harshly judged, denounced for their involvement in or proximity to violence. Such judgments are not necessarily wrong, but they obscure an uncomfortable reality: We are all implicated in this dirty work, even if the people who do it are conveniently hidden from us.
Hughes argued that the persecution of Jews proceeded with the unspoken assent of many supposedly enlightened Germans, do prisons work essay, who refrained from asking too many questions because, on some level, they were not entirely displeased. This was the nature of dirty work as Mr. As extreme as the Nazi example was, this dynamic existed in every society, Mr. Hughes wrote, enabling respectable citizens to distance themselves from the morally troubling things being done in their name.
Contemporary America runs on dirty work. Others qualify as such by catering to our consumption habits — the food we eat, the fossil fuels we burn, which are drilled and fracked by dirty workers in places like the Gulf of Mexico. The high-tech gadgets in our pockets rely on yet another form of dirty work — the mining of cobalt — that has been outsourced to workers in Africa and to foreign subcontractors that often brutally exploit them.
Like the essential jobs performed by grocery clerks and other low-wage workers during the Covid pandemic, this work sustains our lifestyles and undergirds the prevailing social order, but privileged people are generally spared from having to think about it. One reason is that the dirty work occurs far away from them, in isolated institutions — prisons, slaughterhouses — that are closed to the public.
Another reason is that the privileged rarely have to do it. Although there is no shortage of it to go around, do prisons work essay, dirty work do prisons work essay America is not randomly distributed. It falls disproportionately to people with fewer choices and opportunities such as high-school graduates from depressed rural areas, undocumented immigrants, women and people of color.
Many of these workers are victims in their own right, do prisons work essay, susceptible not only to exploitation and physical injury — as is true of so many people in low-status occupations — but also to another, less familiar set of hazards, owing to the unpalatable nature of the jobs they do.
For dirty workers, do prisons work essay, these burdens include stigma, self-reproach, corroded dignity and shattered do prisons work essay. You become more callous. The moral slide Mr. As I have reported elsewhere, mental health staff routinely violate medical ethics by standing by while incarcerated people with mental illness are mistreated and abused.
For example, do prisons work essay, in the months after Mr. Krzykowski lost her appetite. Her hair fell out. She struggled with guilt and shame and was eventually diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, do prisons work essay.
The result is a form of moral inequality that mirrors the economic kind. Just as the rich and poor have come to inhabit starkly different worlds, an equally stark gap separates the people who perform the most thankless, ethically troubling jobs in America and those who do prisons work essay exempt from these activities.
To be sure, plenty of elite white-collar professionals — Wall Street bankers who sell shady financial products, or software engineers who design hidden spyware — do jobs that are morally suspect, do prisons work essay.
But for white-collar workers who grapple with the ethical consequences of what they do, lavish salaries and bonuses can offset whatever discomfort they may feel. These elites are also less likely to be shamed and stigmatized for what they do than to be envied, lessening the impact of the ethical compromises they may feel they are making. This is not to say that they are not accountable for their actions. But pinning the blame for dirty work solely on the people who carry it out can be a useful way to obscure the power dynamics and the layers of complicity that perpetuate their conduct.
In prisons as elsewhere, the conditions that give rise to such work are a product of collective decisions, after all, reflecting our values, the social order we unconsciously mandate and what we are willing to have done in our name. In the case of Mr. What we owe dirty workers is the willingness to see them as our agents and to grapple with our own complicity. We also owe many of them the right to have their stories listened to with respect and curiosity.
How might this look? One evening not long ago, I attended a ceremony in a small chapel at the V, do prisons work essay.
After the veterans spoke, members of the audience formed a circle around them, linking arms and delivering a message that all dirty workers deserve to hear. The Times is do prisons work essay to publishing a diversity of letters to the editor. Here are some tips. Follow The New York Times Opinion section on FacebookTwitter NYTopinion and Instagram. Home Page World Coronavirus U. Politics New York Business Tech Science Climate Sports Olympics Wildfire Tracker Obituaries The Upshot International Canada Español 中文网 Today's Paper Corrections Trending.
Today's Opinion Columnists Editorials Guest Essays Letters Sunday Review Video: Opinion. Automotive Games Education Food Health Jobs Love Magazine Parenting Real Estate Style T Magazine Travel. news Home Page World Coronavirus U.
Does Prison Actually Make a Difference?
, time: 19:15Essay Fountain - Custom Essay Writing Service - 24/7 Professional Care about Your Writing
Jun 11, · Prisons are considered schools of crime. Emotions play crucial role in phase of incarceration. Some researchers have indicated that criminals don’t cope well in prisons whereas critics have argued prisons do cope criminals (Frank et al, 93). According to research conducted by Hurd ( ), prisons don’t work at all Aug 13, · In , Everett Hughes, an American sociologist, published an essay titled “Good People and Dirty Work” that drew on conversations he’d had in postwar Germany about the mass atrocities of work with writers from EssayErudite. so the chance that someone will find out about your using our essay writing service is slim to none. We do not share any of your information to anyone. Our Services. When it comes to essay writing, an in-depth research is a big deal. Our experienced writers are professional in many fields of knowledge so
No comments:
Post a Comment